Casting the net wider… How retail media can reach beyond endemic advertisers.

Fisherman casts a net with water droplets flying

In our article in the last issue of Radar (Issue 13), Making Room for More: Unlocking Retail Media’s Long Tail, we discussed how retailers could expand the reach, diversity and vibrancy of their retail media networks by accessing the long tail of smaller potential advertisers.

There is another way to achieve many of those same objectives and, at the same time, potentially inject some serious ad-spend heavyweights into the mix: invite in advertisers who do not actually sell products through the retailer.

At first glance, you might wonder how that works. After all, doesn’t it remove some of retail media’s biggest advantages? There is no advertised product sitting on the shelf nearby and, crucially, there may be no purchase at the end of the journey for the retailer to measure through its own EPOS data.

So, what’s the attraction?... I think the answer becomes clearer if we break these advertisers into two distinct groups: near-endemics and non-endemics.

Near-Endemics: Close Enough to Belong

Near-endemic advertisers do not sell directly through the retailer, but have an obvious relationship with a category, product or shopping mission that the retailer does offer.

A good example might be the Sustainable Energy Authority of Ireland (SEAI), which administers grants to homeowners making energy-efficiency improvements, advertising within a large DIY retailer where many of the products needed to make those improvements are sold.

Or a home insurer advertising within a jewellery retailer or department. A travel company appearing within a pharmacy or grocer’s toiletry category around summer holidays. An EV manufacturer alongside home-energy or charging products.

The advertiser may not be on the shelf, but its presence makes sense.

In fact, I would go further than that. Done properly, this sort of advertising should have the potential to enhance the customer experience. The retailer already has a shopper thinking about a particular project, need or occasion and introduces something relevant which may help them complete it, make a better decision or solve a related problem.

There is another way advertisers could add something more tangible too. A retailer could negotiate a genuinely exclusive offer or benefit for its customers as part of the media partnership. Whether that is a preferential rate, additional service, special access or some other meaningful advantage, the advertising then becomes more than a paid message: it becomes something the retailer is bringing to its customers. And that opportunity need not be restricted to near-endemics; the right non-endemic partner could do exactly the same.

If retail is a service industry, that feels like an important test. The advertising should not merely be tolerated because it is relevant enough. Ideally, it should add something to the experience.

True Non-Endemics: Then There Is the Audience

The second group is more interesting still… These are advertisers for whom the attraction is not really the retailer’s products at all. It is the retailer’s audience, and its ability to create rich, highly relevant segments based on genuine shopping behaviour.

That potentially opens the door to some of the biggest-spending categories in advertising: banking, insurance, mobile phones, automotive, travel and many more. Imagine, for instance, how interesting a privacy-compliant audience of shoppers displaying purchase behaviours consistent with having recently started a family could be to a car manufacturer, life insurer or financial services company.

Or imagine a bank being able to reach high-spending households, younger adults who have recently joined a retailer’s loyalty programme, or families displaying behaviours that might suggest they are entering a different life stage… Now it starts to get interesting!

And the retailer has something here that most traditional media owners would dearly love to possess: an ongoing customer relationship, repeated behavioural data and, crucially, permission to communicate with those customers.

Nor does the opportunity necessarily end at the retailer’s own website, app, emails or stores. Those first-party audiences can potentially be activated off-site too, through privacy-safe partnerships with social platforms, broadcasters and other online publishers.

So the argument for non-endemic advertisers investing in retail media can be compelling. And from conversations with former colleagues in Irish media agencies, there certainly appears to be pent-up demand here… So, what’s stopping us?

The Big One: Customer Experience

There is one particularly significant consideration… Customer experience.

As we have said before, retail is first and foremost a service industry, and a retailer’s primary responsibility is to its customers and their experience. However glittering the media revenue prize might be, a retailer cannot afford to jeopardise its reputation or compromise its customer environment in pursuit of it.

Nobody wants to see a grocery website begin to resemble a generic advertising portal. Nor should a customer who has given a retailer permission to communicate with them suddenly find themselves bombarded with advertising simply because somebody is prepared to pay for access.

For near-endemics, the benchmark feels relatively straightforward: does this advertising genuinely complement the shopping mission and, ideally, make the customer experience better?

For true non-endemics, the judgement may be more nuanced. Relevance may come from the audience rather than the shopping mission, but the same principle should still apply. The communication needs to feel appropriate to the relationship the customer has with the retailer.

The question therefore should not simply be: “Is this relevant enough to run?”

Perhaps the better question is: “Does allowing this advertiser into our environment add something for our customer… Or does it take something away?”… That is a considerably higher bar… And I think it should be.

Before You Knock on the Agency Door…

As we discussed in the last article, media agencies can provide retailers with access to a much broader pool of advertisers without requiring the retailer to build relationships with every one of them individually. That becomes even more important here. Many of the banking, insurance, automotive, telecoms and travel budgets we are talking about will already sit within wider media plans controlled or heavily influenced by those agencies.

The demand may therefore be there, and the argument for opening retail media to near- and non-endemic advertisers may be compelling, but retailers need to be properly equipped before they start knocking on the doors of media agencies and asking for a share of budgets currently being spent on search, social, display, OOH or television… There are some table stakes.

Firstly, the proposition has to be easy to understand and relatively easy to buy. Agencies are accustomed to clear audience definitions, formats, pricing, specifications and timelines. Retail media cannot arrive with a completely different language and expect agency media planners to do all the translating.

Digital inventory also needs to be professionally served and measured. For onsite media, increasingly that means technology capable of delivering, targeting, optimising and reporting campaigns to standards agencies already expect from other digital channels. Over time, some degree of programmatic accessibility is likely to become increasingly important too.

And then there is reporting… Retail media often talks proudly about its measurement advantage, and rightly so. But extraordinary measurement delivered extraordinarily slowly is not necessarily much use to an agency trying to optimise a media plan. Reporting needs to be robust, understandable and, increasingly, fast.

Retailers also need clear rules around the advertisers and categories they will accept, where this media can appear, how often customers might see it and what happens when commercial opportunity clashes with customer experience… Because somebody within the retailer ultimately has to be prepared to say no.

A Bigger Opportunity, with Bigger Responsibilities

The opportunity is undoubtedly there…. Near-endemic advertisers can broaden the retail media proposition in ways that feel entirely natural to the shopper and, at their best, actually enhance the experience. True non-endemics can introduce substantial new advertising budgets and allow retailers to compete for money that has historically gone nowhere near retail media.

But this is not simply about finding more places to put more advertising. It’s about recognising that a retailer owns something extraordinarily valuable: a trusted customer relationship, a rich understanding of shopper behaviour and permission to communicate with people within an environment they have chosen to enter.

Get it right, and opening retail media beyond endemic suppliers could make the market considerably larger, more diverse and more interesting. Get it wrong, and the retailer risks trading away some of that hard-won trust and customer goodwill for a few extra lines on the media revenue spreadsheet.

As ever with retail media, the opportunity is not simply in selling the space… It is in knowing how, and when, to use it.

Next
Next

Making room for more… Unlocking retail media’s long tail.